A very common question out there among home owners is how to determine if they need to replace their windows. Many times this question is driven by exposure to massive marketing campaigns aimed at energy efficiency. For example the 2009 stimulus package included a tax credit which at the time of writing expires December 31st 2010 has prompted many recent advertisements on the subject.
One a side note, for windows to qualify for the energy tax credit they must have a 0.30 U-Factor. A U-factor is a measurement of the windows ability to prevent heat from escaping. The R value is the inverse of this measurement. In short, the lower the U-factor the greater the R value which is the insulating ability of the window. One should consider that this measurement is based on the window assembly which is determined at the factory. It does not however include the installation of the window, which if poorly done, can eliminate any benefit of a low U-factor.
The campaign for energy efficiency may take the front seat in your process for determining if you want to replace your windows. This is expected when you consider the push by government agencies and window manufactures in this area. One nationally recognized window manufacture says their windows “can help you spend less to the utility company each month” and who wouldn’t like that. But let’s step back and look at where the push to replace your windows is coming from; home improvement stores, windows manufactures, home improvement contractors, and energy efficiency and weatherization companies.
Before you make a decision to replace your windows based on energy efficiency you must consider the product cost, the installation cost, and the window life cycle. In one study by Dr. William Hill, professor of Urban Planning at Ball State University, homes in the state of Indiana that were enrolled in its Energy Conservation Financial Assistance Program indicated replacement windows yield about an annual fuel savings of 1.4%. However the average replacement cost was $3,350. Taking in account the life cycle of the windows, which can range from 10 years to 30 years depending on sources, the payback period for the windows is approximately 400 years. Based on energy efficiency alone replacement does not produce overall savings.
If energy efficiency is your main concern then upgrades to your building’s insulation and weatherization of your windows with storm windows or caulking will yield greater savings.
The choice to replace windows should be based solely on the following criteria:
- Windows are damaged and inoperative.
- Personal taste.
The first may be avoided. Almost all wood windows can be repaired at a significantly lower cost than replacement. Vinyl and aluminum windows can also be repaired in varying degrees. If a contractor claims they cannot be repaired get a second opinion. The criterion of personal taste maybe satisfied by paint, stains, changing hardware, or different window treatments.
What I would like you to take away from this is the fact that energy efficiency rarely, if ever make sense as a decider for window replacement. Make sure you do your homework before choosing to tear out your existing windows.
No comments:
Post a Comment